Best MLS Players of All Time – Past & Present Legends of Major League Soccer

In the modern day, Major League Soccer, has become a global stage for some of the best players around the world to showcase their talent, from older icons of the league like David Beckham and Landon Donovan to newer ones like Lionel Messi and Luis Suárez at Inter Miami. Clubs like the LA Galaxy, FC Cincinnati, Atlanta United, Real Salt Lake, Columbus Crew, Portland Timbers, and the New England Revolution have all been home to game-changing players who have defined eras by winning the MLS Cup, securing the Supporters’ Shield, or being named the Landon Donovan MVP of the season.

With unforgettable moments on the pitch and game-changing performances across every position, these players have left their mark on MLS history, whether that is in the past or present. In this post, we'll highlight the greatest players to have ever played in MLS, and what made them standout figures in league history, from their impact on the pitch to their influence on American soccer as a whole.

The Best MLS Players Past and Present

Lionel Messi

Lionel Messi joined Inter Miami in 2023 and instantly transformed the club's fortunes, leading them to their first Leagues Cup title in his first season. Widely considered as the greatest player of all time, Messi brought unmatched global attention to Major League Soccer and raised the standard of the league on and off the pitch.

Luis Suárez

Luis Suárez reunited with Messi at Inter Miami, adding elite finishing and vision in the final third during the 2024 season. Known for his goal-scoring ability and sharp instincts, Suárez quickly became one of the best MLS players in his first year and helped Inter become a top contender.

David Beckham

David Beckham joined the LA Galaxy in 2007, making headlines around the world and changing the landscape of American soccer forever. His arrival not only brought international attention to MLS, but also laid the groundwork for the league’s growth—including eventually owning Inter Miami and signing the first two players on this list.

Thierry Henry

Thierry Henry starred for the New York Red Bulls, where his skill, leadership, and professionalism elevated the club’s status and inspired a new generation of MLS players. His years in Major League Soccer showcased his creative brilliance and reinforced his legacy as one of the greatest players to play in the league.

Kaká

Kaká became the first superstar for Orlando City SC, serving as captain and the face of the expansion team in their early MLS seasons. A former Ballon d’Or winner, he brought elite playmaking and class to the midfield, helping elevate the club's profile and setting a high standard for future MLS players on and off the pitch.

David Villa

David Villa led New York City FC in goals for four straight seasons and was named MVP in 2016 after a standout season. As a World Cup winner and proven goalscorer, Villa helped NYCFC grow into a major MLS club while showing why he was one of the best players in the league.

Zlatan Ibrahimović

Zlatan Ibrahimović played two unforgettable seasons for the LA Galaxy, scoring 52 goals and delivering jaw-dropping moments that made headlines around the world, including his amazing debut performance against LAFC. Despite not winning an MLS Cup, his charisma and skill left no doubt he was one of the most talented stars to ever step onto an MLS pitch.

Carlos Vela

Carlos Vela made history with LAFC, scoring 34 goals in a single season to win the Supporters’ Shield and MLS MVP in 2019. His combination of flair, vision, left-footed precision, and popularity make him one of the greatest players in Major League Soccer to date.

Javier Hernandez (Chicharito)

Javier "Chicharito" Hernandez joined LA Galaxy with enormous expectations and found form in his second season, finishing among the league’s top scorers. A Mexican icon, he boosted MLS visibility and added another chapter to the club’s rich striker legacy alongside Robbie Keane and Zlatan.

Landon Donovan

Landon Donovan is a true American legend of Major League Soccer, winning six MLS Cups and becoming the all-time assists leader while starring for the LA Galaxy and San Jose Earthquakes. The MLS Cup MVP trophy is even named after Landon Donovan, a testament to his lasting impact on American soccer.

Clint Dempsey

Clint Dempsey, another American legend, brought edge and swagger to Seattle Sounders FC, helping lead them to consistent playoff runs and becoming one of the most iconic MLS players of his era. His fearless style and clutch goals solidified his spot among the best MLS players in league history.

Robbie Keane

Robbie Keane scored 83 goals in 125 games for the LA Galaxy, winning three MLS Cups and being named MVP in 2014. His finishing, movement, and leadership made him one of the best players to ever play for the LA Galaxy, and Major League Soccer in general.

Wayne Rooney

Wayne Rooney gave D.C. United an instant spark, delivering viral moments, stunning long-range goals, and elite vision in the midfield. Despite a short MLS career, his influence on and off the pitch made him a standout in MLS history eventually becoming a coach of D.C United.

Gareth Bale

Gareth Bale joined LAFC in 2022 and scored one of the most important goals in MLS Cup history—a dramatic equalizer in the final against Philadelphia Union. Though he played fewer games, his impact in that moment was pure gold for the club and league.

Andrea Pirlo

Andrea Pirlo brought elegance and experience to New York City FC, controlling the midfield with his trademark composure and precision. While he wasn’t the flashiest player, his role in growing the club’s identity and attracting bigger talents earned him respect in MLS.

Didier Drogba

Didier Drogba joined Montreal Impact in 2015 and scored 11 goals in his first season, instantly becoming a fan favorite. His physical dominance and big-game experience added star power to MLS during a critical growth period.

Steven Gerrard

Steven Gerrard spent two seasons with the LA Galaxy, bringing leadership and world-class passing to the midfield. While his MLS career was brief, his presence added to the Galaxy’s tradition of signing global stars.

Frank Lampard

Frank Lampard joined New York City FC and found his rhythm in the second season, scoring 12 goals and helping the club reach new competitive heights. Though injuries limited his playing time, his status as a Premier League legend brought credibility to the new MLS franchise.

Gonzalo Higuain

Gonzalo Higuain led Inter Miami during their early years, finishing as one of the team’s top scorers and helping establish the club’s identity. His performances and leadership paved the way for Messi and Luis Suárez to elevate the team further.

Lorenzo Insigne

Lorenzo Insigne brought Serie A stardom to Toronto FC, showcasing creativity, technique, and attacking flair on the left wing. Despite injury struggles, his quality makes him one of the most technically gifted players in recent MLS seasons.

Ashley Cole

Ashley Cole played three seasons with the LA Galaxy, bringing stability and leadership to the left back position. A respected figure in the locker room, he helped mentor younger MLS players while maintaining a high standard on the pitch.

Bastian Schweinsteiger

Bastian Schweinsteiger joined Chicago Fire and played multiple roles—from midfield general to emergency center back—while elevating the professionalism of the team. His work ethic and tactical awareness made him a respected figure in MLS.

Jordi Alba

Jordi Alba joined Inter Miami alongside Messi, adding pace, chemistry, and defensive balance on the left flank. His arrival strengthened one of the most star-studded squads in MLS history, contributing to Inter’s title hopes.

Luciano Acosta

Luciano Acosta has become the heartbeat of FC Cincinnati, helping transform the club into Supporters’ Shield winners and title contenders. The Argentine playmaker was named MLS Cup MVP in 2023 and is considered one of the best creative forces in Major League Soccer.

Denis Bouanga

Denis Bouanga became the breakout star for LAFC, scoring 20+ goals in the 2023 season and leading the club back to the MLS Cup Final. His explosive speed and finishing ability make him one of the best MLS players currently lighting up the league.